Learn › Credit Genius Luci lessons › Lesson 5
What Debt Collectors Can and Can’t Do
Who’s calling, and what rules they play by
When you fall behind and an account gets sold or handed off, a debt collector usually takes over. They’re playing the same game you are, but they’ve read the rulebook. Time you did too.
The federal law that covers them is the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, plus a newer rule from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau called Regulation F. These cover personal debts like credit cards, car loans, medical bills, student loans and mortgages, and they mainly apply to companies collecting someone else’s debt. Business debts aren’t covered.
Make them prove it
Rule number one: don’t agree to anything, don’t admit the debt is yours, and don’t take their word that it’s valid. A phone call or a text message proves nothing. Here’s how the proof works, step by step.
On that first call, text or email, don’t verify anything. Not your identity, your address, your phone number, your Social Security number, your birth date, or the name of the original creditor. Give them nothing. They have to prove everything.
It often sounds like friendly, natural conversation: “I just need to confirm I’ve got the right person, can you give me the last four of your Social?” It isn’t small talk. It’s a technique built to make you feel like you have to answer. You don’t. If they say they can’t discuss the account until you verify, that’s fine. Tell them to send everything in writing to the address they have on file, and hang up.
This protects you from scammers too. The CFPB says not to share your personal financial information unless you’re sure the collector is legitimate, and the FTC keeps shutting down “phantom” collectors who chase debts people don’t even owe.
Step 1: The validation notice. The collector has to send you a validation notice with their first contact or within 5 days after it. By law it has to include:
- That it’s from a debt collector, and who they are
- The name of the creditor the debt was owed to, and who owns it now, plus the account number. You can also ask in writing for the name and address of the original creditor, and they have to give it to you.
- An itemization: what you owed on a certain date, plus any interest and fees added and payments or credits since then
- How much they say you owe now
- The exact date your dispute window ends
If they never send it, that’s a violation of federal law. Write it down and keep every record.
Watch out for texts. Collectors text a lot these days, and sometimes it’s to a number you haven’t had in years. If they say they “sent” your notice by text or email, you may never have seen it, or it may have gone to whoever has that number now. A collector isn’t allowed to discuss your debt with your kids, relatives, employer or a stranger, so a text about your debt landing on someone else’s phone is a problem for them, not you. Either way, don’t reply with any details or agree to anything by text. Ask for the notice by mail, and keep screenshots of every text.
Step 2: Your 30-day window starts when you get that notice, not when they first call. The notice tells you the end date. Think of it as two separate stretches: the first 5 days are their job (getting you the notice), and the 30 days after you receive it are your window. If they’re late sending the notice, you don’t lose any rights. Your 30 days still don’t start until you actually get it.
Step 3: Dispute in writing inside that window and ask them to verify the debt. Once they get your dispute, they have to stop collecting until they send you verification. Ask for real paper from the original creditor, not a printout the collection company made up:
- The signed agreement or contract
- Statements from the original creditor showing the charges and the payments you made
- Proof of the chain of ownership: who sold the debt to whom, and proof that your specific account was part of the sale. A general bill of sale for a big batch of accounts, with yours supposedly “in there somewhere,” doesn’t show that.
The law doesn’t spell out exactly what verification has to include, and collectors often send the bare minimum. But if they ever take you to court, it’s on them to prove you owe it and that they own it. That’s often where collectors come up short.
Once you dispute, it has to show as disputed. If the collector reports the debt to the credit bureaus, or keeps reporting it, after they know you dispute it, they have to report it as disputed. Check your reports. If it doesn’t say disputed, that’s a violation of federal law, and it’s worth a complaint to the CFPB.
Step 4: You don’t have to wait for them. You can dispute a collection with the credit bureaus at any time, right away, for free. That’s a separate right from the collector’s 30-day window.
This is the single most important step in this whole lesson. Mark three dates on your calendar: the day they first contacted you, 5 days after that (when the validation notice is due), and the day your 30-day dispute window ends (it’s printed on the notice). Send everything in writing, keep copies, and use certified mail with a return receipt so you can prove when they got it. Until you’ve seen real proof, don’t agree, don’t admit, don’t pay. Don’t hand them any of your own paperwork or financial information, and don’t agree to anything during this process. They have to prove it to you. You don’t have to prove anything to them.
What collectors can’t do
| They can’t… | What that looks like |
|---|---|
| Call at bad times | No calls before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. your time, unless you agree |
| Call over and over | More than 7 calls in 7 days, or a call within 7 days after you talked with them about the debt, is presumed to break the rule |
| Call you at work | Not once you tell them you can’t get calls there |
| Keep texting or emailing | Every text and email has to give you an easy way to opt out, like “Reply STOP” |
| Post about your debt on social media | Nothing public, not even posts only your friends can see. Private messages are allowed unless you tell them to stop. |
| Harass you | No threats of harm, no obscene or profane language, and no threatening to send the police or have you arrested. Not paying a debt is not a crime. |
| Lie to you | No lying about the amount, no pretending to be a lawyer or a government official, no threatening arrest or a lawsuit they don’t really plan to file, and no threatening to take your property unless they have the legal right to and really intend to. On debts like credit cards and medical bills, they can’t take anything without first winning in court. |
| Add made-up charges | No interest or fees your contract or the law doesn’t allow |
| Tell other people | They can only discuss your debt with you, your spouse, your lawyer, or someone the law treats as standing in for you (like a court-appointed guardian or the executor of an estate). With anyone else, like your kids, other relatives, neighbors or your boss, they can only try to get your contact information. They can’t say what it’s about, and they can never say you owe a debt. |
| Sue on old debt | They can’t sue, or threaten to sue, over a debt that’s past your state’s time limit. Lesson 6 covers that clock. |
Car loans are the exception. If you’re behind on a loan where the car itself is the collateral, many states, Texas included, let the lender repossess it without going to court or warning you first. But they can’t “breach the peace” doing it. In Texas, that generally means a repo agent can’t:
- Get past a locked gate or open a closed garage door to get to the car. A gate that only opens with a code, key or remote is locked to anyone who doesn’t have one.
- Threaten or use force against you or anyone else, or damage your property
- Keep going after you object to the repossession on the spot
And nobody, collector or repo agent, can threaten to bring the police to come into your home and take your things or have you arrested. Calling with that threat breaks the rules in the table above. Taking anything out of your home takes a court order, not a phone call.
Check your state’s law first. Everything in this table is the federal floor. Your state can add more protection on top, including on who a collector is allowed to talk to about your debt. Before you decide whether a collector crossed the line, look up your state’s debt collection law (your attorney general’s website is a good start) or ask a consumer attorney.
Your moves
- Want them to stop contacting you? Tell them in writing. After that, they can only confirm they’ll stop or let you know about a specific action, like a lawsuit. Stopping contact doesn’t erase the debt, though.
- Have a lawyer? Once you tell them, they have to talk to your lawyer instead of you.
- Keep a log. Date, time, who called, what they said. Save every letter, text and email.
- Never pay on a phone promise. Any deal to settle or set up payments: get it in writing first. If it’s not in writing, it doesn’t exist.
- Be careful with old debt. In some states, even a small payment or a written “yes, that’s mine” on an old debt can restart the clock for a lawsuit. Know where you stand before you pay a dime (lesson 6).
- Got sued? Don’t ignore it. Respond by the date on the court papers, yourself or through a lawyer. If you don’t, the collector can win by default, and a court order is what lets them garnish your wages or bank account. Many federal benefits are generally protected from garnishment.
Extra protection in Texas
Texas has its own law, the Texas Debt Collection Act (Texas Finance Code, chapter 392). Two things make it worth knowing:
- It reaches further. The federal law mostly covers collectors working on someone else’s debt. The Texas law defines a debt collector as anyone who collects a consumer debt, which can include the original lender collecting its own account.
- Collectors have to be bonded. A third-party debt collector has to file a $10,000 surety bond with the Texas Secretary of State before collecting in Texas. You can look a collector up in the Secretary of State’s Debt Collector Search.
Other states have their own rules too. If you’re outside Texas, your attorney general’s website is a good place to start.
Sources
FTC: Debt collection FAQs (call hours and limits, what collectors can't do, stopping contact, 30-day dispute, lawsuits, time-barred debt)
CFPB: Debt collection rule executive summary (7-in-7 call rule, electronic opt-outs, social media)
Texas Secretary of State: Third-party debt collector FAQs ($10,000 bond, Debt Collector Search)
CFPB: What information does a debt collector have to give me? (validation notice contents, 5 days, 30-day window from receipt, collection pause)
CFPB: How do I tell if a debt collector is legitimate or a scam?
FTC: Action halting a phantom debt collection scheme (March 2025)
FTC: Vehicle repossession (repossession without court in many states, breach of the peace)
Upsolve: Repossession laws in Texas (breach of the peace examples: locked gate, closed garage, force, continuing after you object; police involvement)
Texas Accredited Repossession Professionals: Consumer information
General credit education only, not legal or financial advice. We don't review credit reports, file disputes or offer credit repair services.
Get the next lesson
